There is such a thing as municipal librarian machismo. The
literary blogger Maud Newton received a marvellous blast of it a
few years ago, after some snippy comments about New York public
libraries. Those libraries, a friend wrote to her, were not just
for readers of her blog:
"No, my library is for the 40-something woman who is trying to
divorce her drunk of a husband and for the secretaries spinning
their wheels on the subway holding pace on their life with a
page turner and dreaming of a husband like the one in her
pink-covered novel.
"My library is for three-year-olds who have never held a book
before and reluctant readers whose window for real literacy is
open for a matter of months; it is for the religious freak and
the politically disenfranchised. My library is for the homeless
and the millionaire both and a place where each get exactly the
same focused, personal service."
Scott Douglas is, from this perspective, a classic example of a
real librarian. The patrons he deals with at two branch
libraries in Anaheim, California, are unliterary enough to
furnish him with an entire chapter on death threats. (Although,
after reference research, he discovers that no one who has
threatened to kill their local librarian has ever yet gone
through with it.)
When his first branch is closed for refurbishment, a young
teenager who calls in to reminisce still remembers his
performances at story time.
He is also an enlightening guide to the changes in local
libraries over the past decade and a bit. While some of his
observations are California-specific ("I think it's fair to say
that if you take the bus to the library there's an 85 per cent
chance you're clinically crazy and a danger to society"), most
will draw a smile - or a yelp of rage - from any holder of a
council library card.
The second chapter of this loosely structured book concerns "the
Day of the Gateway"; that is, the day that 12 cardboard boxes
arrived from Gateway computers, ready to change libraries for
ever.
Douglas is at this point a mere library page, as junior as it
gets, but the shift in favour of the young, computer-literate
male ("We men need to band together," a fellow librarian tells
him, "Sometimes I feel these women are conspiring") helps
sharpen his sense of vocation.
Computers are a constant presence in the stories that follow.
The eccentric library users Douglas celebrates and mocks are
much the same as they would have been 25 years ago: teenagers,
crotchety old people ("seniors", in his American service-speak),
the homeless, the mentally unwell.
But where once a librarian's campfire tales might have concerned
the things that people leave under the front flap, here it's the
guy who tries to put the print card in the disk drive, the
teenagers who hacked the time-limit program, what you do when
someone asks for help printing out porn, and the ructions when
they banned MySpace.
Eating in the library provides another sub-plot: first popcorn
on Saturday (it brings children, but also mice), then fast-food
vouchers as a way to promote reading (Douglas slips extras to
the threadbare and hungry), then vending machines.
Douglas may waver - can't there be something at least a little
healthy in those vending machines? - but finds he can bring
himself round to anything that will increase library use.
He sees his story as that of someone who began thinking that
libraries were about books, and has learned that, like Soylent
Green, jails, churches, etc, what they're really made of is
people.
His case for modernisation never rises to the rhetorical heights
attained by Maud Newton's friend, because his is a cooler sort
of librarian machismo.
Parts of this book were originally published on the website of
the literary magazine McSweeney's, and it retains that site's
fake-naive comic tone, adding further design whimsy (lots of
footnotes, digressions "for filing" set in ITC American
Typewriter) and touches of real naivety.
That does not mean Douglas is any less confident of the need for
change: libraries must serve food, he states in his afterword,
because they have to compete with bookstores.
"I've often asked fellow librarians how long before libraries
start to realise the modern library isn't a monopoly, that
competition is fierce, and that they have to run the building as
such?"
This is sensible. But I'd be happier if there were more talk of
libraries competing with bookstores on range of books.